All these scanners are basically junk, to put it very nicely. Make sure you can return and get a full refund after you find out that many unhappy people are right when they give bad reviews for these cheapo scanners. This page is not intended to be a fair and balanced review of these products. We have tested three scanners such as those listed below and we can say that we can only agree with the negative reviews. One scanner we tested is the Brookstone and the other is the VuPoint. You are just not going to get a good transfer to digital with cheapo scanners. It is a shame that big name stores will sell this junk to trusting customers. We can only assume that it is out of technological ignorance that they do this rather than evil intentions.
Please note that there is a very good reason why these units are so cheap.
Junk is cheap. But this kind of junk is not cheap in the long run. If you ever read any positive reviews about this junk, it may just be because the people reviewing them do not know that the quality is so poor, having never seen what a good scan will look like. Don't let the desire to save a few bucks ruin the quality of your whole slide or photo collection digitization. Send us ten of your slides and let us scan a free demo disk for you and then you can purchase this junk and see the difference yourself. There is a reason why so many of these scanners mostly look the same. They ARE the same, just different cases. It seems like this SVP company spends a lot of time coming up with new outside cases to cover their inside junk. New lipstick on old pigs.
We probably could have put one hundred of these pieces of junk on this page because it seems like there must be one hundred different companies in China making these things, all using the same basic insides. We don't have the time because we are busy giving our customers excellent scanning at a reasonable price. These slide scanners represent a sampling of what is out there. Caveat emptor: Let the buyer beware.
| Scanner | Comments Amazon.com Cheapo scanner negative reviews |
SVP PS9000 black Digital Film 35mm
|
Really hate this! ------------ ------------------ I was forced to return this product because software does not work. My thanks to the seller for full money back.SVP 3-IN-1 Digital Photo/Slide/Film Scanner (SVP PS-9000) -------------------- SVP-PS-9000 Cheap, cheap, cheap! --------------- Very disappointing |
Flashpoint scanner
|
BEWARE: this is the same machine sold under different brand names and they are getting "DON'T BUY" REVIEWS. Don't buy it! It simply doesn't work I bought the Flashpoint 35mm Film and Slide Scanner, which the description says,"...allows you to turn your negatives and slides into five megapixel digital images with the press of a button." The software installed easily enough, but when I fed in some slides, every image was overexposed. For example, a slide that pictured my Mom posing with a Clydesdale at the Budweiser brewery, came out as a ghostly image that showed only the brown parts of the horse--everything else was ghostly white and unrecognizable. I tried over two dozen slides and only a few came even close to looking like the original. The images were so bad, that they couldn't be fixed with either the image enhancing software that came with the product or with Photoshop. Amazon outsourced this product to Adorama in New York. To their credit, Adorama responded immediately with a downloadable, pre-paid UPS shipping label. I simply packed everything back in the original box and sent it back at no cost and no questions asked, other than why I didn't like the product. So a big thumbs up to Adorama and a big thumbs down to this crappy product. |
Wolverine fd200 scanner
|
SORRY--This scanner didn't do it for me The user guide that comes with it is very poorly written, almost like it was written by a person from another country that doesn't quite have command of the English Language. Some of the instructions are rather "squirrely" and you have to put the user guide down and just play with it to figure out what is going on. After playing with it for an hour or so, I realized that this is more of a plastic toy than a true 35mm quality scanner, so I returned it. If you just have a bunch of old slides you want to slap into digital format and you don't care about the quality, then this might work for you. Otherwise, you might be better off to look at some of the flatbed scanners that also do slides. It takes more time to scan them, but what you get is going to be a lot nicer to look at, especially if they are of family members or memories that are important to you. ---------------- ------------------ Amazingly bad. Stunningly bad. Really awful
|
Wolverine Data SNaP100
|
Extremely Disappointed ------------------- The photo scans all had a white, ghostlike rectangular reflection of the interior of the scanner chamber....every picture had the white rectangle across 1/3 of the scanned image. The second problem, even more appalling, was the image moniter wasn't installed correctly and hung crookedly inside the machine. Couldn't view the preview withoug tilting the machine on it's side. Third problem....the Slide scanning feature DID NOT FUNCTION....period. Wouldn't even turn on. Like the wires were not connected inside. WHO INSPECTED THIS JUNK? I found a different photo scanner at Bed Bath And Beyond (0n clearance) for $40 and it takes much better photo scans. I will send my slides for scanning through COSTCO....50 for $17.99 and 29 cents each for additional slides (minus a $5 off coupon !). So $53.99 will get me a much better result than this $130 piece of junk. Stay away from this product. ------------------- Horrible Quality |
Veho 5 MP 35mm Negative and Slide Scanner
|
Worst Photo purchase this year --------------- Bad purchase ---------------- Don't buy this one! |
Imagelab FS5CO5 Slide and Negative Scanner
|
Product description is false 35mm images created are Square - because part of image is missing Blurred, not sharp as in the original image Excess contrast The unit cannot correct for a films curvature. Part of image may be in focus and part not. I would recommend it only to my enemies and the blind. --------------- Cuts slides on the sides -------------- Faces are very overexposed -------------- While the colors of the scanned images did seem less sharp than in the original prints, I had no objection there, and, as I said, I have software to fix that. I even have batch processing software so that I can make the same color correction to a bunch of images. Picking out scratches and dust wouldbe more time-consuming, but this could be done too. I found the scan resolution to be fine. Unlike someother reviewers, I didn't have trouble loading the trays once I got them open. It's possible that the company had changed the design. The way the trays latched was a bit tricky, and you might damage negatives if you were careless about opening a loaded tray. The odd latch seemed to pop open somewhat unexpectedly as you were trying to open it. The trays seemed quite secure when loaded and closed. I only scanned negatives from one envelope, and transferred the SD card rather than using the usbUSB cable. I also did not attempt to use itin the battery-powered mode. I also didn't use slides. Therefore, I can't comment on any of these aspects. However, I did find (as at least one other review noted in its body) that the scan missed a significant amount of the long direction of the negative image. Another reviewer estimated 10 - 15 percent, which seems right. If you do any photography where you've framed the edges of the image somehow while shooting, or if you have images where you used the whole field to capture your subject, you will not like the results at all. If you only have subjects in the middle of the frame and everything else is quite background filler, then you may not care. This flaw probably made me look at the images with less care for quality than I might have done otherwise. Bottom line to me is that a slide/negative scanner must capture the entire image being scanned, anything else is abject failure. |
Innovative Technology 35mm Negative and Slide Converter
|
Innovative Technology 35mm Negative and Slide Converter to PC ------------------ You get what you pay for! ------------------- I would not recommend anyone buying this 35mm Negative and Slide Converter. I could not get it to work on either of my two computers. The software would not load with Windows or Vista. When I tried to get help from Technical Service their web page and telephone was no longer in service. I could not find any address to return it. I gave up and bought a HP Scanjet G4050 which worked perfectly scanning over 1,000 35mm Slides. My experience was a learning one. You get what you pay for! ----------------------- -------------------- |
Innovative Technology The Ultimate Film and Negative Scanner
|
Waste of money... ------------------ ITNS-500 Piece of Junk -------------- Disappointed |
Pana-Vue Pana-Scan 35mm Negative and Slide Scanner
|
Really hard to use ----------- Never was able to use this, it doesn't work on my computer. I have been working with someone from Argraph, the manufacturer via email for a couple of weeks trying to make it work, in the end they said this scanner has problems on some HP systems. Definitely didn't work on mine. They pointed to the 64 bit AMD processor as the problem, even though it is supposed to work with 64-bit systems. Other issues include: - Poor instructions |
Slide Scanner Gets History Out of the Shoebox
|
Scanner is a waste of money ---------------- Bad Product -------------- This item is no good ------------- TERRIBLE PICTURES ----------------- Should have read the reviews first |
Pandigital Photolink One-Touch PANSCN05
|
Will Be Returning It ------------------- Photo/Film/Slide Scanner Digitizer Liked the unit seemed to be everything I wanted except... the unit was defective and would not scan slides. The other features worked fine except the slide scanning. This is why I picked this unit. I returned it to Amazon for a refund. ------------------- Doesn't work on older slides The product description just says it does photos, slides, and negatives. It's a big oversight to fail to mention that it won't work for the vast majority of people's slides. |
Kodak 4x6 Personal Photo, Slide and Negative Scanner (P461)
|
Very Disappointing 1. Odd color shifts appearing in the resulting scans. Some redeeming qualities include the speed at which the unit scans, which is fairly fast. The size and weight also is very appealing. Most of the descriptions of this product fail to mention that it will also work on battery power which is a great selling point if only the quality of the output was acceptable. In conclusion, while no scanner in this class and size is going to produce the kind of scans available from a flatbed scanner, this scanner leaves of lot to be desired with the scan quality. I expected better from Kodak. I will be returning the unit and spending my money on a different option. |